Second, Fantasia is far too large. I can't believe it was eleven years ago, but she became the winner of American Idol in 2004. Her rendition of Summertime was memorable.
However, this is how she looks now:
The very first American Idol winner, Kelly Clarkson, too, seems to have a problem:
You say, well, not too bad. But that is a posed photo from redbook. Here is something from FAT WORLD wiki:
On the other hand, Bernadette Peters looked great: