Total Pageviews

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

BIOMETHANOL VERSUS PLUG-IN ELECTRIC VERSUS BIOBUTANOL FOR TRANSPORT

I noticed there are two books now available on the biofuels delusion.  Ever the optimist, I today sent out to a select list of bioexperts a message seeking their input about what it will cost to produce a biofuel from algae.  Here is my message:


Dear XXXX:



Every so often, I ask the question, is a production cost of $3/gallon possible for biofuels from algae. Thus, I thought I'd expand this response to a few friends for their possible comments. Yes, your experience with this field certainly has shown the reality.  You have been absolutely right...so far.  But can we hope for something more by 2020?

The problem regarding ground transport is that plug-in electric vehicles are not the sensible future pathway, but no one of any substance is interested in my biomethanol economy with the direct methanol fuel cell. About aviation, we do need a next generation jet fuel that is not hydrogen, nor fossil.  I'm further going on the basis that global warming is real and a significant carbon tax will be enacted within a decade.  While the Chicago Mercantile Exchange had crude oil only at $95/barrel in December of 2018 (which, interestingly enough, is $6/barrel higher than just last week), oil prognosticators have always been wrong in the past, so the combination of Peak Oil and China/India continued growth can only result in another spike beyond $150/barrel within ten years.

We thus might have this short period to do the best that we can developing biofuels from algae, including some successful genetic engineering.  We need to spend ten times our current rate, and you know this is not going to come from the private sector.  Our current society is not conformed to make smart long term decisions...until it is too late, so I hold little hope for any paradigm shift in intelligence.

Given the above, it comes down to:  CAN BIOFUELS FROM ALGAE BE PRODUCED FOR $3/GALLON ($126/barrel) or less by 2020?  Can you, or anyone reading this, offer any scenario for this potential?  (Feel free to send your comment only to me if you don't want to share with the cc list above.)

Aloha.


A respected non-delusional member from industry responded with $12-$20/gallon.  He has been saying this for some time, so I place him at the other end of the spectrum from certain entrepreneurs and government officials suggesting that $1/gallon might be possible.  Myself, I hope for $3/gallon ($126/barrel)...someday with the right R&D. A second individual, from the Department of Energy,  in response, asked what I thought about biobutanol.  I answered:


Dear YYYY:



The analysis is as simple as this:  methanol is the simplest liquid biofuel, which with minor retrofitting can use the present infrastructure, plus, this is the only liquid capable of being directly fed to a fuel cell.  Life is more complicated than this, but I hear that the Farm Lobby has effectively prevented the USDOE from developing the Direct Methanol Fuel Cell (DMFC) for vehicles.  Toshiba is already selling the DMFC for portable applications.  For the same space, a DMFC can power an electronic device five times longer than a lithium battery.  

I worry about plug-in vehicles, for they will primarily use coal electricity for the next couple of decades.  Then, if a fuel cell powered car can take you five times further, why be saddled with this limited battery technology, especially since most of the commanding patents for the lithium ion battery (which, by the way, is the last battery) are held by the Japanese.  Let us own the patents for our own future.  Hint:  there is an opportunity in transport-size DMFC technology.

By the way, I think hydrogen remains a longshot for being produced, transported and stored to compete with all these other options over the next decade.  This gas, though, makes some sense for next generation aviation, but that is a generation or two or more away.

A couple of years ago Cobalt Biofuels announced cheap butanol from biomass.  This reminds me of that cheap jet fuel from algae a certain federal agency suggested last year.  But, I guess if BP and DuPont are interested in butanol, they must know something I don't.  As a biochemical engineer, I have concerns about producing biobutanol from biomass, because any hydrolysis/fermentation system will just take too much time, equipment, energy and money.  

Others have said, why not synthesize butanol starting with biomethane or biomethanol.  The logic here defies common sense.  Of similar illogic, there is at least one project announced for Hawaii to grow biomass, manufacture a biodiesel, then feed it to a combustion turbine.  Why not burn the original biomass (and not the one which produces biodiesel, for these plants are very inefficient)?  There actually is an answer to this nonsense:  they are stuck with a combustion turbine which the utility promised would use a renewable fuel.

Too many of these entrepreneurs (and even some government officials) talk about $1 and $2/gallon production costs, but the reality looks closer to $3-$5/gallon.  Mind you, we definitely must significantly upgrade R&D on many of these biofuel alternatives because oil could suddenly shoot up to $168/barrel ($4/gallon), with an added carbon tax.  We need to have a couple of these options ready when that happens.

All these discussions led me to send the message out seeking hope and comfort for the algae pathway.  For now, I still remain convinced that gasification/catalysis of biomass into methanol is the most sensible pathway, especially if the DMFC can be developed in a decade.  This might, however, not be possible.  We just don't know.  We haven't even tried.

Aloha.


Such is the state of the field in the future of sustainable ground transportation options.

-
The Dow Jones Industrials dropped 18 to 10,526, with world markets more up than down, and the Japan Nikkei surging 171 to 9,470, no doubt affected by Prime Minister Naoto Kan fending off Ichiro Ozawa in an intra-party vote.  Gold surged at one point to an all-time high ($1276.50/toz), ending plus $22/toz to $1269, with crude oil now at $76/barrel.

-
There are three storms in the Atlantic:


1.  Hurricane Igor is up to 155 MPH, but all models show it veering north, then east.


2.  Julia is now a hurricane at 105 MPH, but is even more non-threatening to land.




3.  In the Gulf of Mexico, Tropical Storm Karl is east of the Yucatan Peninsula, will move west over land, recover over water, then become a hurricane before striking Mexico

There is also a disturbance east of Taiwan, and expected to move north.
-

No comments: