Total Pageviews

Friday, June 26, 2020

COVID-19: How is it possible that the medical field was off by a factor of 10 in the mortality rate?

From Worldometer,  COVID-19 new deaths:

           DAY USA   WORLD   Brazil   India   South Africa
June      1      638    3189           480      223         40
              2      730    3053           732      200         22
              3    1134    4669         1232      221         50
             4     1083    4928         1269      259         37
             5     1031    5511         1492      275         56
             6       975    4906         1008      286         60
             7       706    4253           910      297         44
             8       586    3157           813      266         82
             9     1093    4732         1185      246         82
           10       982    5163         1300      388         48
           11       904    4951         1261      394         74
           12       791    4603           843      389         70
           13       702    4229           890      309         69
           14       331    3263           598      321         57
           15       425    3415           729      395         88
           16       849    6592         1338        ?           57
           17       809    5264         1209      341         49
           18       747    5123         1204      342         63
           19       719    5066         1221      366         94
           20       573    4428           968      307         46
           21       267    3338           601      426         53
           22       363    3880           748      312         61
           23       863    5465         1364      468        111
           24       808    6071         1103      424        103
           25       649    5179         1180      401          87

Summary:
  • Stable day for the world, but the USA recorded the highest number of new cases yesterday, 39,972, breaking the previous record of 36,291 set on April 24.
  • Yet, President Trump and VP Pence keep remarking that all is well, and, of course, not wearing a face mask.
  • WHO declared the the latest Ebola outbreak is over, after two years and 2,280 deaths.
Here is the basic dilemma that has been troubling me for months.  In all those daily reports from the various sources, the mortality rate for the World and U.S. has been around 5%.  This makes no sense because this death rate should be around 0.5%.  So why?

Well, yesterday, the CDC officially indicated that the number of COVID-19 cases is really ten times more than we see.  Huh?  Let me first provide some background to summarize the important facets of this disease.

Our World in Data has a comprehensive, but totally confusing compilation of analyzed data on the mortality (also called death and estimate case fatality) rate of COVID-19.  I will do what I can to bring some sanity to this figure,

To begin, the Worldometer source I have been utilizing for months now shows the following:

                    Total Cases  Total Deaths  Deaths/cases  Deaths/1Mpop

World           9,702,189       490,988          0.051                   1,245
USA             2,504,588       126,780          0.051                   7,567
India               491,170          15,308          0.031                     356
Qatar                91,838               106          0.001                 32,708

If you like to think in terms of percentages, that 0.051 means 5.1%.

In comparison with other similar ailments (FCR is same as mortality rate and death rate):

Virus                           Estimated Case Fatality Rate (FCR)

SARS-CoV                                             10%
MERS-CoV                                            34%
Seasonal Flu                                      0.1% to 0.2%
Ebola                                                  40% to 50% 

COVID-19                                        0.1% to 5%


Notwithstanding the above, the consensus for the seasonal flu is closer to 0.1%.  However, even this figure is deceptive, for that 0.1% is based on those who said they had the flu.  It is suspected that four times more of the population actually contracted the flu (in COVID-19 the factor is 10) and never became a medical statistic.  As such, the mortality rate for the seasonal flu should really be 0.04%!  Thus, if, say COVID-19 ends up with a mortality rate of 0.4%, then this would be ten times worse than the real death rate of the seasonal flu.

Of course, this rate depends on age, here comparing the flu with this new coronavirus:


The zero for 0-19 is not zero, but something very close to it.

Worse than old age is if the patient has one or more pre-existing health condition, which raises the death rate by a factor of 12:


More specifically, in addition to the just added condition of being pregnant:

Then, too, ethnicity is a factor:


Ethnicity makes a big difference:
  • Overall, American death rates from COVID-19 data have reached new highs for all race groups:
  • 1 in 1,500 Black Americans has died (or 65.8 deaths per 100,000)
  • 1 in 2,300 Indigenous Americans has died (or 43.2 deaths per 100,000)
  • 1 in 3,100 Pacific Islander Americans has died (or 32.7 deaths per 100,000)
  • 1 in 3,200 Latino Americans has died (or 31.1 deaths per 100,000)
  • 1 in 3,600 White Americans has died (or 28.5 deaths per 100,000)
  • 1 in 3,700 Asian Americans has died (or 27.7 deaths per 100,000)
So back to the purpose of this posting, respected sources say that the COVID-19 mortality rate will eventually be proven to be less than 0.5%.  So why the reported 5% for the World and USA?  Chances are that the deaths are reasonably reliable.  However, the general sense in the field is that the number of cases, for whatever reason--testing, asymptomatic cases, whatever-- could well be 10 time higher than those reported.  At least that is what the CDC yesterday reported.  If true, then the 5% mortality rate in the World and USA should be closer to 0.5%.  A rather mysterious unknown  is asymptomatic cases.  Tomorrow, I might go into this second unknown, for these are the ones who primarily transmit the disease.

Way back on April 8 I guessed that the mortality rate would settle at 0.7%.  On May 6, I brought this number down to 0.5%, although indicated that it should be lower.  What are some current guesses?
  • CDC: 0.26%
  • Marc Lipstick of Harvard:  0.2% to 1.5%
  • Michael Calderwood:  around 0.5%
  • Stanford:  0.12% to 0.2%
The bottom line is that the 2.5 million reported cases in the U.S. should be 25 million.  Herd immunity is attained when 60% of the population have been infected or vaccinated.  So we have a ways to go, for this means that 200 million will need to be immune.

So when do we get this vaccine?  No one knows for sure, but the good news is that scientists did find a vaccine for the H1N1 virus, which caused the previous pandemic.  However, they failed to find vaccines for MERS and SARS, and both are a different strain of the coronavirus.

Also too, there is yet no vaccine for simple viruses that cause malaria, HIV/AIDS, chikungunya and dengue fever.  Science has found vaccines for polio, tetanus, the flu, hepatitis A and B, rubella, measles, whooping cough, pneumococcal disease, chickenpox, diphtheria, and mumps.

Polio is an example of a science victory.  There was a polio epidemic in 1916, just before the Spanish Flu.  Read this article.  Scarily similar to our current COVID-19 Pandemic.

In the early 1950's there were up to 50,000 cases, with 15,000 becoming paralyzed. While anyone can contract polio, 50% are children under the age of 5.  Jonas Salk (left) came up with a vaccine injection in 1955, followed by Albert Sabin's oral (pill) vaccine in 1961.  Both work well, for the number of cases per year has dropped below triple digits.  Neither got a Nobel Prize.

Finally, if found, how effective will a COVID-19 vaccine be?  Probably better than the seasonal flu vaccine, as the optimal mix for the coming season has to be guessed way ahead of time for stockpiling purposes.  COVID-19 is one specific virus. There is no vaccine for the common cold because there are 200 different virus that cause this sickness.  

Last season (2019) the flu vaccine was 39% effective, which turns out to be about equal to the 40% annual average.  Caught the flu in the 2014-5 season?  The effectiveness was only 19%.  Worse, only 45% of Americans last year took this shot.  The percentage/year has always been less than 50% since 2010.  Multiplying the two and you get less than 20% immunity in the country.  Remember, you need at least 60% to gain any kind of population immunity.

I'm in the year 1954:
  • Marilyn Monroe marries Joe DiMaggio, but they divorce before the year is over.
  • Hudson Motor Car Company merges with Nash-Kelvinator Corporation forming American Motors Corporation, which later involved Renault, then Chrysler, Daimler-Benz...and now Fiat.
  • Nuclear powered USS Nautilus christened by Mamie Eisenhower.
  • First mass vaccination of children against polio.
  • The Oscar Mayer hotdog car, the Wienermobile, appears.
  • U.S. explodes hydrogen bomb on Bikini Atoll in the Pacific Ocean.
  • The Viet Minh defeats the French at Dien Bien Phu.
  • First televised boxing match, where Joey Giardello knocks out Willie Tory at Madison Square Garden.
  • Bill Haley and his Comets record Rock Around the Clock, starting rock and roll.
  • U.S. Air Force Academy founded in Colorado.
  • President Eisenhower gives his Domino Theory about Southeast Asia.
  • April 11 denoted as most boring day in the 20th century.
  • Senator Joseph McCarthy begins hearings on communism.
  • Akira Kurosawa's Seven Samurai released.  Rotten Tomatoes later bestows 100%/97% rating.
  • Roger Bannister runs first sub-four minute mile in Oxford.
  • Diane Leather becomes first female to run a sub-five minute mile in England.
  • The words "under God" added to the U.S. Pledge of Allegiance.
  • First atomic power station opens near Moscow.
  • Great Britain ends food rationing, after 14 years.
  • First issue of Sports Illustrated.
  • The last episode of The Lone Ranger on radio, after 2,956 shows over 21 years.
  • Miss America Pageant broadcast on TV for the first time.
  • Texas Instruments develops the first commercial transistor radio.
  • First Godzilla (Gojira--got 93%/89% rating from Rotten Tomatoes) film premieres in Tokyo.
  • Dow Jones closes at an all time high of 382.74, finally exceeding the 380 of 1929, a period of a quarter century!
  • First documented case of a meteorite hitting a person, in Alabama.
  • Original Hyatt Hotel opens at the Los Angeles International Airport, the first built on any airport property in the world.
  • First Burger King opens in Miami, Florida.
  • First kidney transplant in Boston.
  • First electric drip brew coffeemaker, in Germany.
  • TV dinner introduced.
The top songs of 1954 in ten minutes.  Little Things Mean a Lot by Kitty Kallen is the #1 song of the year.  Here she is on the Perry Como Show.

I was asked to include this commencement address on "How you living?"  Ten minutes long.  Every life  can matter.


-

No comments: